The evening that never ends
The light is off, and a moment later your child is standing in the doorway. Then they call out from bed, then they come to show you that something itches. Each trip takes a minute, but together they take the whole evening, and with every visit the adult's voice has a little less calm in it. This guide is about children aged roughly 3–10 who are healthy and safe but still drag out going to sleep. It does not cover night fears, nightmares or methods that involve leaving a crying child.
The sequences, phrases and examples in this article are editorial suggestions. We are not promising that your child will stop getting up after a certain number of evenings.
A short, fixed sequence
In its guidance on moving from a cot to a bed, the American Academy of Pediatrics recommends keeping the same bedtime routine the family used before. A predictable order means fewer things to negotiate: your child knows what comes next, and the adult does not have to invent the evening from scratch.
An example sequence: pyjamas, brushing teeth, toilet, one book, a hug, lights out. Five or six steps are enough. You can draw them on a card by the bed. Repetition matters more than length: the same order on an ordinary Tuesday and on a day when everyone is tired.
Deal with needs before the light goes off
Many trips out of bed have a specific reason. Build those reasons into the sequence before lights out: a cup of water by the bed, a last trip to the toilet just before the book, the door ajar or a small lamp if your child needs one. Ask at the end: “Is anything missing before I switch off the light?” Then a later “I'm thirsty” is easier to take calmly, because the water is already there.
That does not mean your child can never call you. If they are ill, frightened or something has happened, go to them. The plan below is for trips that happen every evening and mainly serve to stretch out contact.
A calm return to bed
The AAP describes a simple approach for a child who gets out of bed: calmly and quietly lead them back and tell them they need to stay in bed now. Keep the interaction brief and boring, because even angry attention can encourage another trip. Praise your child for staying in bed, not for getting out. The AAP warns that you may need to repeat this many times over several evenings in a row. This AAP guidance is about young children after the move from a cot, but the approach itself carries over easily to older ages.
In practice: one sentence, always the same, such as “It's time to sleep now. See you in the morning.” No explaining why sleep matters, and no pointing out how many times it has been. In the morning, you can name exactly what went well: “Last night you stayed in bed after the book until you fell asleep.”
The bedtime pass
A study by Moore and colleagues (2007) included 19 children aged 3–6 who resisted going to bed. They were randomly assigned to two groups. In one, the child received a card – a pass – that could be exchanged for one parental visit or one trip out of the room after lights out. Once the pass had been used, parents did not respond to further calls. Children with the pass left their rooms, called out and cried significantly less often than children in the comparison group, settled more quickly, and the effect held at three months.
Earlier case reports from 2006 (Freeman) involved four three-year-old boys. There, the pass was exchanged for a short, specific thing lasting under three minutes: the toilet or one more hug. Then the child handed back the card and returned to bed. For one child, the pass alone reduced resistance but did not remove it; resistance stopped only once not responding to further calls was added.
What these studies don't show
These are small US studies with children up to age six, carried out with families reporting difficulties at bedtime. The pass worked alongside planned ignoring of further calls; we do not know how well it works entirely on its own. Nor do they show how the pass works for children with anxiety, illness or sleep disorders.
Our suggestion combines the pass with a gentler rule: once the card has been used, any further trips end with a calm walk back to bed and the same single sentence. If your child is crying from fear or is unwell, the pass does not matter – you go to them.
Bringing it in at home
Make the pass together during the day: a piece of card, a drawing, their name. Agree what it can be exchanged for, such as the toilet, water or a hug, and that once it is used, the card stays with the parent until morning. In the evening, at the last step of the sequence, put it on the shelf by the bed.
An older child, aged 7–10, can suggest the rules themselves: what the pass means, where it lives, what happens if it is not used. For some children of this age, an agreement that they can lie quietly with a book under a lamp for a short while after lights out matters more than the card. That is our example, not a research finding.
To begin, choose one thing: set out the bedtime sequence or make the pass. The calm return to bed applies either way.
Sources
- Moore, Friman, Fruzzetti, MacAleese, J Pediatr Psychol 2007: Evaluating the Bedtime Pass Program for child resistance to bedtime – a randomized, controlled trial — 19 children aged 3–6, a pass for one visit or trip out, fewer trips and less calling out, effect at 3 months. Small sample; the pass was combined with ignoring further calls.
- Freeman, J Appl Behav Anal 2006: Treating Bedtime Resistance with the Bedtime Pass — exchanging the pass for a short activity under 3 minutes, handing back the card, results with four three-year-olds. Four cases; component analysis with one child.
- American Academy of Pediatrics (HealthyChildren.org): Big Kid Beds: When to Switch From a Crib — calmly and quietly leading the child back, brief and boring, praise for staying in bed, repeating over several nights, keeping the same routine. Advice for parents of young children.
Read next
A screen-free evening, a picture routine and specific praise for last night's success support a calm bedtime.
