The “marshmallow test” tells us less than is often claimed
Popular articles often describe a study in which preschoolers could eat one treat straight away or wait for two. Earlier work linked longer waiting with better outcomes years later. In 2018, Tyler Watts, Greg Duncan and Haonan Quan revisited the question with new data, focusing on children whose mothers had not completed college. Each additional minute waited at age 4 was linked to slightly better school achievement at age 15, but the association was roughly half the size reported in the original studies. Once family background, early cognitive ability and the home environment were taken into account, it shrank by about two-thirds. Links with teenage behaviour were smaller still and rarely statistically significant.
What does this mean for parents? A few minutes of waiting at age four does not decide a child's future. The study was observational: it shows associations and did not test whether practising waiting at home changes anything. So in this article we do not treat saving as “willpower training”, but as a practical skill for planning purchases.
What the CFPB suggests
In its “Money as You Grow” programme, the US Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) notes that children aged 3–5 find it hard to plan for the future because they are so focused on today. For children aged 6–9, it says saving is easier when they know exactly what they are saving for, and it suggests talking about how a story character changed their savings plan. These are educational materials, not effectiveness studies.
Preschoolers: waiting counted in days
For a child aged 3–5, “in two months” means very little. If you want to try saving, we suggest a goal that can be reached quickly: stickers, a small ball, a chosen fruit at the market. Measure the wait in events your child knows: “after two Sundays”, “when Grandma comes”. At this stage, experiencing the whole journey matters more than the amount: wanting, waiting, buying.
You might start the conversation with a question: what fun things can we do today without spending money? It shows that not buying something now doesn't mean an empty day.
Ages 6–9: a specific goal and the freedom to change the plan
Ask your child to name exactly what they are saving for: not “something to play with” but a particular board game or a particular building set. Check the price together. Then talk through three things: where the money will come from, roughly how long the wait will be and what happens if another temptation appears along the way.
Changing their mind is allowed. When, in week three, your child wants to spend the savings on something else, ask instead of forbidding it: “If you buy this now, when will we get back to the building set?” The decision can be your child's if it is their money and the choice is safe. Afterwards, talk without judging: “How do you feel about that choice now? And the building set: keep saving or change the goal?”
Ages 10–12: a longer horizon and working it out together
An older child can save for something more expensive, such as a bike or a trip. You can work out together how many weeks it will take at their current income and agree whether the family will contribute. If it will, say so openly. Let your child record each amount themselves: it is their plan.
If the goal feels too far away, split it into stages with visible checkpoints. The point is not rewards for each stage but making progress visible. With a long-term goal, prices can change, so check the current price together now and then. If it has gone up, your child can decide: save for longer, choose a cheaper model or change the goal.
When waiting is hard
At some point your child may cry in a shop because the thing they love is “right now” and the money is not there yet. You can name it briefly: “You really want it, and waiting is hard.” Don't quietly add the missing amount just to end the situation, and don't mock the goal. If the family decides to help, make it a clear decision rather than a reward for tears.
With a child aged 6–9, translating the temptation into the goal helps, without moralising. “That keyring costs about as much as you save in a week. The building set would then be a week further away. What do you choose?” This doesn't forbid the purchase; it shows the cost of the choice in a unit your child understands: weeks of waiting. An older child can work out the difference themselves. If the decision is “I'll buy it now”, don't bring it up reproachfully next time. The goal stays written down and you can return to it from the next deposit.
All examples, amounts and phrases in this guide are our editorial suggestions. We do not promise that saving will teach your child patience in other situations.
When the goal is reached
Treat the day of the purchase as the end of the plan. After a few days, ask whether the item is what they expected and whether they would like to save for something similar next time. Disappointment is information too: the next goal can be chosen more carefully. If the item turned out well, ask what helped them keep saving: the written goal, shorter stretches of waiting, or the conversations along the way. Those answers will help with the next plan.
Sources
- PubMed: Watts, Duncan, Quan (2018), Revisiting the Marshmallow Test: A Conceptual Replication Investigating Links Between Early Delay of Gratification and Later Outcomes — the link between waiting at age 4 and achievement at age 15 was half the size of the original studies and fell by about two-thirds after accounting for family background and early abilities. An observational study focusing on children whose mothers had not completed college; it did not test waiting practice.
- CFPB: Money as You Grow — Talking about financial decisions — children aged 3–5 find planning for the future hard; children aged 6–9 are helped by knowing exactly what they are saving for. Educational material, not a study.
- CFPB: Learn to save with Money Monsters (PDF, ages 6–9) — the idea of a savings goal and questions about changing a savings plan. Educational activity from 2022.
Read next
Jars organise pocket money, while hard waiting and family agreements about contributions are next steps.
