Why a request sometimes doesn’t land
An adult calls from the next room: “Shoes!” The child is building a tower of bricks and doesn’t look up. By the third repetition, the voice is louder and both sides are more irritated. Often this is not about unwillingness. The request may not have been heard, may have been too vague or may have contained several instructions at once.
This guide is about the request itself: how to say it and how much time to allow for a response. We do not promise that your child will always do what you ask. The aim is to remove obstacles on the side of the message, so your child has a real chance of understanding what is expected.
Sources and their limits
We draw on two materials for parents. In its “Essentials for Parenting” series, the CDC advises, among other things, getting your child’s attention before a request, using a simple statement rather than a question and giving one direction at a time. The “How to Give Clear Directions” handout from the Backpack Connection series, shared by the National Center for Pyramid Model Innovations (NCPMI), describes common reasons children don’t follow directions and suggests waiting about five seconds.
Both materials are mainly about young children. The example phrases and the adaptations for older children are our editorial suggestions. These are not the results of a study testing one technique.
First, come close and connect
The NCPMI handout notes that parents often give directions from a distance or in passing, and a child busy playing simply doesn’t hear them. The CDC suggests getting close, making eye contact, using your child’s name and considering crouching to their level.
In practice, that means a few steps into the room instead of calling from the kitchen. For example: you crouch next to the bricks, wait until your child looks at you and only then speak. If they are absorbed in play, you can first comment on what they are doing (“That’s a tall tower”) and then move on to the request.
Say what to do instead of asking
“Will you put your shoes away?” sounds polite, but it is a question. The CDC points out that questions give a child the option to refuse. The NCPMI handout gives a similar example and suggests instead: “Put your shoes by the door.” You can keep it courteous with “please” and a calm voice, which the CDC also recommends.
A second change: say what your child should do, not only what they shouldn’t. Instead of “Stop running!” – “We walk indoors.” Instead of “Settle down” or “Be good” – something concrete: “The bricks stay on the rug.” Both sources point out that general phrases are hard for a child to turn into action.
Where possible, the CDC suggests two choices: “Put on the grey trousers or the blue ones.” Your child decides the detail and the goal stays clear. Be careful with “let’s” too: according to the CDC, use it only when you really plan to help.
One request at a time
“Go upstairs, brush your teeth and pick up your bricks” is really three tasks. The NCPMI handout describes a multi-step direction like this as too long for a young child and suggests giving one direction at a time. First: “Brush your teeth.” When that is done, the next request.
With an older child, from about 7–8, you could try two steps or a short written list. That is our suggestion. If the task falls apart again, go back to one step. The CDC also reminds parents to match the direction to the child’s age: not yet being able to do something is not the same as disobeying.
Allow time and don’t repeat on a loop
The NCPMI handout suggests a sequence: give the direction, silently count to five, ask your child to say back what they need to do, wait again and, if needed, encourage or help. Helping can simply mean taking your child’s hand and walking to the bathroom together.
According to the same handout, repeating the direction over and over within those few seconds can teach a child that they don’t need to respond the first time. An editorial example: “Put your shoes by the door,” silence, five seconds, then: “What do you need to do with your shoes?” When the shoes are in place, a short “Thanks, the shoes are by the door” is enough.
Choose the requests that really matter
NCPMI advises parents to “pick your battles”: avoid insisting on directions that are not important and easily escalate into a big struggle. Choose a few important requests you will see through, such as fastening a seat belt or putting down a knife. For the rest, you can let go or turn the request into a suggestion.
The CDC adds that practising is easiest when you have time to follow through. The morning just before leaving is a hard moment to test a new approach. A calm afternoon and one daily task are a better start.
When the request still isn’t followed
The CDC advises staying calm, getting your child’s attention again and repeating the direction. Before deciding that your child is refusing, check: did the request reach them, was it clear and is the task within their abilities? With an older child, you can ask directly: “What’s stopping you from doing it now?” Sometimes the answer is simple: the game is about to save, and two minutes sort it out.
Sources
- CDC: Tips for Giving Directions — getting attention first, a statement rather than a question, one direction at a time, two choices, “let’s” only when helping, matching the direction to age; written for parents of young children.
- NCPMI / TACSEI: How to Give Clear Directions (Backpack Connection) — reasons children don’t follow directions, positive phrasing, waiting five seconds, asking the child to restate, picking important requests; a handout for parents of young children, updated 2018.
Read next
Moving on from play, a picture routine and specific praise complement a clear request.