RudiKids
PL Google Play

RudiKids · Blog

How children learn to help others

Tools for tidying up together

Very young children can help others on their own initiative. Laboratory studies also suggest that a material reward for helping may weaken that willingness. What does this mean for everyday life with a preschool or school-age child?

What studies with toddlers showed

In 2006, Felix Warneken and Michael Tomasello of the Max Planck Institute in Leipzig reported in Science that children of around 18 months, not yet talking or just starting to, readily helped others reach their goals in a range of situations. The authors point out that such helping requires two things: understanding what the other person is trying to do and wanting to help them. In the same study, similar but less consistent behaviour was seen in three young chimpanzees.

In 2008, the same researchers looked at what happens to helping when a reward is involved. In the first part of the study, 20-month-old children received a material reward, praise or nothing for helping. In the next part, those who had received a material reward were less likely to keep helping than children who had been praised or not rewarded. The authors concluded that even the earliest helping is intrinsically motivated and that external rewards may weaken it.

What these studies don't show

These were short laboratory experiments with very young children and simple tasks. They do not cover preschoolers or school-age children, and they did not look at household chores or longer periods. Nor do they show that praise increases helping: the 2008 finding is that a material reward was linked to less helping than praise or no reward. We treat them as a hint not to turn spontaneous help into a transaction, not as a recipe for raising children. The examples and phrases below are our editorial suggestions.

Leave room for help, even if it takes longer

A child who runs over when you are carrying the shopping wants to take part. Instead of “leave it, I'll do it faster”, hand over a light bag or ask them to open the door. A small child's help often slows things down. It is worth accepting where it is safe and you have a little time: unpacking the shopping, laying the table, watering the plants.

When there is no time, say so plainly and offer a different role: “I need to be quick now, but could you hold the keys for me?” Your child learns that their wish to help matters, even if this particular task is too hard this time.

Thanks instead of payment

When your child, unprompted, picks up something a younger sibling dropped or brings Grandad his glasses, there is no need to reach for a sweet or a sticker. Say thank you and name the effect: “Grandad can read his paper now. Thank you.” That sentence says what the help changed for the other person, not what it is worth.

This doesn't mean your home can't have any agreements about pocket money or rewards. It is worth keeping them separate from ordinary kindness to others, though. If your child starts asking “what do I get for helping?”, you can answer calmly: “We help each other because we're a family. We don't pay for that.”

When help ends in a mess

Water spilled while watering the plants or a mug broken while laying the table is a common price of a small child's help. Your reaction in that moment tells your child whether it is worth trying again. Instead of “why did you have to touch that?” (easy to say when stressed), say briefly what you will do now: “The water spilled. Can you fetch a cloth? We'll wipe it up together.” If something was too heavy or too fragile, offer a different part of the task next time: plastic cups instead of glasses, a smaller watering can, carrying the napkins instead of the plates. Clearing up is help too, and your child can take part without shame.

Helping outside the home

Chances to help come up in ordinary situations: holding a door for someone with a pushchair, passing a classmate a crayon that rolled under the desk, taking the neighbour's newspaper from the letterbox. For a child aged 3–5, one small action you do together works well. A child aged 6–9 can spot a need on their own if you ask: “What do you think, does anyone here need help?” A child aged 10–12 can plan help over a longer period, for example shopping for an older neighbour once a week, in agreement with the adults.

Agree safety limits too. Helping adults your child doesn't know happens with a parent or carer present, and your child doesn't have to help when they feel unsure. They can always say “no” or call an adult. Helping peers, at school for instance, has limits too: your child doesn't have to do a classmate's homework or give away their things in order to be seen as helpful.

Don't force it and don't compare

Helping on command stops being helping by choice. When your child doesn't want to help today with something that isn't their responsibility, accept the refusal. Avoid comparisons such as “your brother always helps and you don't”. It is better to notice specific moments when your child helped and describe them without labels, for example: “Ola has her crayon back. That was good help.” You can say that to any child in the family without ranking them.

In short

The wish to help appears early in children. Give it room in everyday situations, accept slower help when you can, say thank you and name the effect, and keep material rewards for other agreements. Remember that the studies involved toddlers in a laboratory; at home, what counts is watching your own child.

Sources

Household chores, sibling cooperation and descriptive thanks are closely related sides of helping.